Menu

Menu

Explore The Old Neighborhood Cafe’s Handcrafted Lunch & Dinner Menu

At The Old Neighborhood Cafe, our menu is inspired by classic deli options and traditional family recipes. Dash in for a quick lunch or sit down with your favorite people to share an unforgettable meal. Satisfy your cravings with a delicious, scratch-made meal at The Old Neighborhood Cafe at Cherry Hill.


Savory Sandwiches, Craft Burgers, Fresh Salads & Specialty Soups at The Old Neighborhood Cafe in Columbia, MO

Salads

All City Salad

Grilled or fried chicken breast on mixed greens, lettuces, tomatoes, cucumbers, shredded carrots, and pickled red onions. Choice of house-made ranch, Italian or balsamic vinaigrette. 

$13
Grandma’s Tortellini Salad

Tortellini, tomatoes, red onions, roasted bell peppers, and dijon dressing. Add grilled chicken or shrimp.

$13
Taylor St. Salad

Mixed greens topped with salami, smoked ham, cubed mozzarella, tomatoes, shredded carrots, bell peppers, pickled red onions, and artichoke hearts. Choice of house-made ranch, Italian or balsamic vinaigrette.

$14

Soups

Rustic Tuscan Minestrone

House Specialty! Onion, celery, carrots, zucchini, spinach, cannellini beans, and ditalini pasta in a chicken and tomato broth. 


Small: $5, Large: $9
Soup of the Day
Small: $5, Large: $9

All soup is served with fresh bread and butter

Sandwiches & Mac

Sandwiches

Katy Trail Classic Chicken Sandwich

Seasoned grilled chicken tossed with dried cranberries, celery, and a creamy dressing. Topped with lettuce and tomatoes served on toasted artisan bread. 

$13
The Goat

Thick-cut smoked bacon, green apples, goat cheese & a balsamic glaze on toasted artisan bread

$13
Aunt Loretta

Thick-cut smoked bacon, sauteed peppers and onions, pepper jack cheese, tomatoes, and mayo on french bread.

$13
Meanie-Mo

Smoked ham, capicola, salami, mozzarella, lettuce, tomatoes, butter herb sauce, and a sprinkle of oregano on French bread. 


$14
Big Commish

French bread stuffed with fried bologna, lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, cheese, and mustard. 


$12
The Cocky Balboa

Grilled Chicken, topped with sauteed onions & peppers, melted together with pepper jack cheese on French bread.


$14
The Cure

Everything bagel with cream cheese, ham, salami, thinly-sliced onion, tomatoes, lettuce, mozzarella, and a balsamic glaze. 


$13
Mama Leitza

Fried chicken cutlet, topped with spinach artichoke dip, mozzarella, and lemony arugula greens on French bread.


$14
Miami Vice

Cuban-style sandwich with pulled pork, ham, swiss cheese, chipotle-mayo, yellow mustard, and pickles.


$14
Golden State Gobbler

Roasted turkey, mashed avocado, thick-cut smoked bacon, spinach, tomatoes, and red onions on a choice of artisan or French bread.


$14
The Big Ruckus

Pulled Pork, fried or grilled onions, pickles and BBQ sauce on a toasted burger bun.

$13

Mac & Cheese

Mac & Cheese
$11
Mac w/ Grilled Chicken
$14
Mac w/ Buffalo Chicken
$14
Mac w/ BBQ Chicken
$14
Mac w/ Bacon & Chives
$14

All sandwiches served with one side

Burgers

The Classic

House-seasoned burger, lettuce, tomato, onion, and your choice of cheese.

$13
Okie Dokie

House-seasoned burger seared in yellow mustard and grilled onions, topped with pickles, lettuce, and mayo.

$13
Big Tex

House-seasoned burger, topped with BBQ sauce, bacon, pepper jack cheese, and fried onion strings.

$13
Pub Burger

House seasoned burger topped with grilled onions, pickles, thick-cut bacon & pub sauce.

$13

All burgers are served with one side

Lunch Box

PB & J
$9
Grilled Cheese
$9
BLT
$9
Bologna & Cheese
$9
Salami & Cheese
$9
Ham & Cheese
$9
Turkey & Cheese
$9

All Lunch Box Specials are served with chips & a drink

Substitute a side for $2

Sides

Bag of Chips
$1.25
Fresh Hand-Cut Fries
Small: $3, Large: $5
Cucumber Salad

Small: $3, Large: $5
Side Salad

upgrade a side + $3.00. Choice of house-made ranch, Italian, or balsamic vinaigrette.

$5
Tortellini Salad
Small $3, Large $5
Cup of Soup

upgrade a side +$3.00

Rotating soup selection. Please ask what the soup of the day is.


Small $5. Large $9
Potato Salad
Small $3, Large $5

FRIDAYS ONLY: Old Fashioned Fish Fry

Fish Fry Special

2 catfish filets, fries, and choice of additional side. Served with housemade tartar sauce.

$18
Fish Fry & Shrimp Special

1 catfish filet and 5 shrimp, fries, and a choice of additional side. Served with housemade tartar & cocktail sauces.

$18
Family Meal

4 catfish filets, 10 fried shrimp, 12 hushpuppies, large fries, and large coleslaw. Served with housemade tartar & cocktail sauces.


$48

Contact the team behind Columbia, MO’s favorite restaurant, The Old Neighborhood Cafe

Want to know more about our menu and dietary options? Contact The Old Neighborhood Cafe to learn more about our options.

Contact Us
Share by: