Menu
Explore The Old Neighborhood Cafe’s Handcrafted Lunch & Dinner Menu
At The Old Neighborhood Cafe, our menu is inspired by classic deli options and traditional family recipes. Dash in for a quick lunch or sit down with your favorite people to share an unforgettable meal. Satisfy your cravings with a delicious, scratch-made meal at The Old Neighborhood Cafe at Cherry Hill.
Savory Sandwiches, Craft Burgers, Fresh Salads & Specialty Soups at The Old Neighborhood Cafe in Columbia, MO
Now Offering...
BREAKFAST! Simple and delicious sandwiches, pancakes, biscuits & gravy and more!
7:00 a.m. - 10:30 a.m.
Fridays & Saturdays only
New Title
Salads
Soups
All soup is served with fresh bread and butter
Sandwiches
All sandwiches served with one side
Burgers
Classic $14
2 house-seasoned smash patties, lettuce, tomato, pickle, onion, cheese (Swiss, pepperjack, American), chipotle-mayo
Okie-Dokie $14
2 house-seasoned smash patties seared with onions & mustard, topped with lettuce, pickles, cheese (Swiss, pepperjack, American) & mayo.
Pub $15
2 house-seasoned smash patties, thick-cut smoked bacon, grilled onion, pepperjack cheese, pickles & signature creamy pub sauce.
Big-Tex $15
2 house-seasoned burger patties, thick-cut smoked bacon, fried onion strings, pepperjack cheese, pickles & bbq sauce.
All burgers are served with one side
Lunch Box
All Lunch Box Specials are served with chips & a drink
Substitute a side for $2
Sides
CATFISH FRY (Friday’s Only)
FISH FRY PLATTER. $18
2 catfish filets, fresh hand-cut fries, creamy Cole slaw, 3 hush puppies, house made tartar sauce.
FISH & SHRIMP PLATTER. $18
1 catfish filet, 5 deep-fried shrimp, fresh hand-cut fries, creamy Cole slaw, 3 hush puppies, house made tartar & cocktail sauces.
FAMILY MEAL. $54
4 catfish filets, 12 deep-fried shrimp, large house salad, large Cole slaw, large fresh hand-cut fries, hush puppies, house made tartar & cocktails sauces.
Contact the team behind Columbia, MO’s favorite restaurant, The Old Neighborhood Cafe
Want to know more about our menu and dietary options? Contact The Old Neighborhood Cafe to learn more about our options.